Brad Nelson
Administrator
עַבְדְּךָ֔ אֶת־ הַתְּשׁוּעָ֥ה הַגְּדֹלָ֖ה הַזֹּ֑את
Posts: 12,261
|
Post by Brad Nelson on Oct 3, 2023 9:58:32 GMT -8
I'm about 1/3 into James Herriot's Every Living Thing. This is another in his series of books. I was not aware that he had written quite a few. I think I recognize a few of these stories from the series. But mostly this reads fairly fresh. Herriot (James Alfred Wight) is a little older and he's no longer the "young-un" of the practice, although this book begins with him in his early 30's. Tristan has moved on to a government ministry job of some type and Siegfried and James (still partners) hire a succession of young assistants. The practice begins to change as they begin to see more smaller pets than the large livestock. Tricky Woo is still (at the beginning of the book) in the picture. Herriot is an imaginative and sensitive writer when it comes to describing his beloved (if often way too cold) Yorkshire. Herriot notes in a bit of honest self-examination that he had steered his daughter away from veterinary medicine (and she eventually became a people doctor). Working with large animals back-in-the-day was extremely dangerous. But Herriot notes that modern techniques (including ways of restraining an animal) means that she probably would have been fine. Things changed in ways he could never have imagined. But you get an idea (in the series, in the books) of just how difficult veterinary work can be in the field. One thing (if honestly told, and there is no reason to believe it is not) is Siegried's and Jame's love of and commitment to animals. The people they work for are often a pain. But they drop everything and bare any hardship to save an animal. It's interesting it's noted that horses a known to be fairly fragile creatures while cows are very hardy. I didn't know that. But apparently cows can weather a lot while horses can go down rather quickly. I can certainly imagine myself finishing this one. I believe I had picked up one of the All Creatures Great and Small books several years ago. But I don't think I read much of it for whatever reason.
|
|
Brad Nelson
Administrator
עַבְדְּךָ֔ אֶת־ הַתְּשׁוּעָ֥ה הַגְּדֹלָ֖ה הַזֹּ֑את
Posts: 12,261
|
Post by Brad Nelson on Oct 5, 2023 9:27:04 GMT -8
This was a delightful book to read. And apparently Every Living Thing was the last one that he wrote.
There are a couple chapters in this that are worth the price of admission.
One is about a vet in the next district (they all have agreed-upon boundaries apparently) whose customers keep coming to Herriot. And only after the fact do any of these customers tell Herriot that their normal vet is someone else. A few of them tell him midstream an exam. And Herriot then has to drop everything and receive permission from the other vet to proceed.
It's unclear why these people are suddenly coming to Herriot. But at the very least, it is suggested it is because this other vet has been out of town a great deal. This other vet is a cantankerous jerk and becomes incensed and accuses Herriot of trying to steal his customers. Cantankerous jerks seem to thrive in Yorkshire.
I'm not sure how much the author embellishes his stories so that they work out into something thematically complete and interesting. But in this case, this is a story that is pretty good and I won't give it away.
The second one that stands out is pretty much a condensed damnation of human nature. Herriot is called out to a home to see a black lab. When Herriot arrives, it takes at least five minutes of ringing the bell and pounding on the door before anyone lets him in. Even then, the man of the house basically takes just enough time to grunt and point to the basket where their dog is lying and suffering.
And then the man joins his wife and children (one gets the impression they are all fat) in front of the boob tube as they all mindlessly stare at it, completely ignoring the vet and their own dog.
Herriot takes a look at the dog and sees that it has been suffering for some time from mange. He is barely able to get the attention of the man again in order to give him some instructions on how to use the powders (sulfur powders, I think) to bathe the dog. He'll check back in a few days, he says, to see how the dog is doing.
And when he checks back, the packets of sulfur powder lie unopened where he had left them. And obviously the dog is no better and still suffering. And the fat family of heavy-smokers is again mindlessly all watching TV and barely can offer Herriot a grunt in response to his inquiries about the dog and the reasons for not bathing it like they should.
Herriot has seen enough and demands a tub and some hot water. He will do the first treatment himself. He goes out to the back yard of this house and proceeds to bathe the dog. There is an older couple next door who watch from over the fence and strike up a conversation with Herriot. And here's where I won't give anything more away. It's worth reading fresh. And if this family isn't at least in Purgatory, then there is no justice in this world.
Siegfried has clearly mellowed out a little since we've seen him, at least in the TV series. There's almost no conflict between him and James. It seems that Siegfried is well pleased with James and no longer motivated to be contentious.
|
|
Brad Nelson
Administrator
עַבְדְּךָ֔ אֶת־ הַתְּשׁוּעָ֥ה הַגְּדֹלָ֖ה הַזֹּ֑את
Posts: 12,261
|
Post by Brad Nelson on Oct 18, 2023 7:16:06 GMT -8
I finished All Things Wild and Wonderful a few days ago. However, I thought Every Living Thing was a superior read. In All Things Wild and Wonderful, it bounces back and forth between James' wartime experience in the RAF and his reminiscences of events in his practice. The wartime stuff, while occasionally of interest, is not quite as gripping. James spends most of his time drilling. In the end, because of some unspoken malady that he has that recurred in some way, he washed out of the RAF eventually and was returned to his practice. But it has some good anecdotes here and there. And he did learn to fly and appeared to be headed to (France?) as part of a ground support crew. But at the last moment, medical didn't clear him. You'd think with a war on that they wouldn't be so picky. But the RAF was insistent on perfect men to be put into the meat-grinder of war. Perhaps (but they don't state it explicitly) with veterinary medicine being (I think) a "reserved" occupation, that may have been why he was returned to civilian life. I've now started the first book which I think was re-titled for the American audience because of the success of the series. Anyway, this appears to be the original book order in Great Britain. The book I'm reading is titled All Creatures Great and Small. And it definitely starts at the beginning (and I don't know if If Only They Could Talk is a prequel or was perhaps rolled into the American first book). We see James venturing into the mythical village of Darrowby and first meeting Siegfried Farnon. And certainly these early accounts bring to mind what I've seen in the original series. And what especially comes to mind is just how amazingly faithful they were to the book in regards to the characters in that original series. There is no discernible difference between the characters in the 1978-1990 series and the ones portrayed in the book. Siegfried, as played by Robert Hardy, is a doppelganger of the somewhat mercurial, stern, and decided hypocritical (in a friendly way), but generally fair and likable, boss of the practice. Peter Davison perfectly captures the lazy, womanizing, irresponsible, prankster Tristan. And Christopher Timothy is very good as the weak and vacillating, but competent and likable, James Herriot. I've never seen such correspondence before between book and television or movie dramatization. This present book is all well and good. But there are perhaps only so many anecdotes you can read that are essentially the same kinds of cases and the same kinds of people. But I'll slog on for a while longer in this one and see if it can hold my interest.
|
|
Brad Nelson
Administrator
עַבְדְּךָ֔ אֶת־ הַתְּשׁוּעָ֥ה הַגְּדֹלָ֖ה הַזֹּ֑את
Posts: 12,261
|
Post by Brad Nelson on Nov 24, 2023 8:45:40 GMT -8
I finished the first book in this series, "All Creatures Great and Small." It's more of the same, of course, but it is interesting reading James Herriot's experiences from the very start.
I think it's obvious that James Alfred Wight (aka "James Herriot") embellished his stories a bit. Even accounting for that, you can't help but be impressed by the Yorkshiremen and especially the Yorkshirewomen. They both worked hard. And the greatest compliment to be bestowed upon a departed wife was "She was a good worker."
Farming in a rather bleak country was hard work. Most farms had sheep and a few dairy cows. Some had pigs. There was little detail in what kinds of gardening they did, but they must have done that as well because they were pretty much self-sufficient. In many cases, people didn't leave the farm for months at a time. In one instance, I think he said this one family hadn't left the farm at all that year except when they had to send their son into town for some necessity.
I wouldn't expect Wight to write anything but good things about his wife. But Helen surely does seem like an extraordinary woman. She was beautiful, good-natured, sturdy, and hard-working. She and James were just about off on their honeymoon when a thick envelope arrived in the mail. It was a request from a government agency (for which they did contract work) to give the local cattle tuberculin tests. I'm not sure where Tristan was, but Siegried was not in a position to both run the practice and do the tests while James was away.
So James, an employee at this point, volunteered to rearrange his honeymoon a bit. They would stay at a charming little inn which they both liked and which was in the vicinity of the cows that needed testing. Rather than complaining and putting up a fuss, Helen volunteered to be James' assistant with great cheer (there is a lot of paperwork involved in these field tests). She was happy to do it and they made the best of it. Upon returning to Skeldale House (Siegfried's large home, site of the practice, and James and Helen's first living space on the third floor), they found a metal plaque alongside Siegried's which announced "James Herriot, M.R.C.V.S". He had been made a partner.
No Yorkshire farm could likely prosper without a good woman. However, it was made plain that much of the hard work a man would endure was in order to have something to hand over to his son or sons. In this modern era of divisions of labor where nearly everyone is a specialist, it's ludicrous over how today's dumbbells judge their forebears harshly for doing the same. There was indeed women's work and men's work. And both were absolute necessities for survival, if not also for a reasonably comfortable living.
And one gets the distinct impression from these books that, without some nag telling them how awful their lives were, Wight often noted how happy and at peace most of these people were, even if they were relatively poor, while the lives of the townspeople were often quite the opposite. Perhaps there's a bit of a soft-focus filter put on this. But I don't think he was lying about what he saw and experienced in the Yorkshire countryside.
|
|
|
Post by kungfuzu on Nov 24, 2023 12:16:53 GMT -8
I visited a friend in Lancashire several times during the late 1970s. I guess I spent between 1 and 2 months there in total. I can only recount my experiences, but the people I ran into were simple, kind and welcoming. Having a young American in their midst was very unusual and I was treated wonderfully.
I think I mentioned it before, but the accents were completely foreign to me. I recall one old man, he would have been around Wight's age or somewhat older, whom I couldn't understand at all. Luckily, I have good ears and it only took me a little while to adjust and could understand most in just a few days. I even got good enough to tell the difference between a Lancashire and Yorkshire accent. No way I could do that today.
I liked the place so much that I wanted to buy a small semi-detached home there. I think it would have cost about US$5,000.00. I couldn't convince my father to do it.
Wonderful memories.
|
|
Brad Nelson
Administrator
עַבְדְּךָ֔ אֶת־ הַתְּשׁוּעָ֥ה הַגְּדֹלָ֖ה הַזֹּ֑את
Posts: 12,261
|
Post by Brad Nelson on Nov 24, 2023 12:44:58 GMT -8
Yes, wonderful memories, I'm sure. The impression I get is that the weather isn't a million miles away from where we get here on this particular part of the Left Coast, although Yorkshire is significantly further north. Yorkshire Latitude 42. Bremerton 47. Yorkshire averages about 4 to 5 degrees colder in the winter and about 7 degrees cooler in August. Where Wight practiced was in the Yorkshire Dales, in the county of Northern Yorkshire, which is in and around the Pennines, so the weather must have been even more bracing, even for Yorkshire.
And I must say, sometimes we do have those Yorkshire years here, especially in the summer. But the impression I get is it's the same relative rainy, drizzling gloom, but just a little colder (which would definitely make it worse). Yorkshire sounds like a wonderful place to visit in the summer.
James Herriot/Wight was born in Sunderland and graduated from Glasgow Veterinary College. He came from a relative big city and seemed to have adapted very quickly to rural life. He loved it. He particularly loved the scenery, slower pace, and lack of crowding.
|
|
|
Post by kungfuzu on Nov 24, 2023 14:01:41 GMT -8
I got to Yorkshire a couple of times during my stays in Lancashire. In those days, there was still a sort of rivalry between Yorkshire and Lancashire, which is perhaps not surprising given their history. Maybe there still is. From what I saw, they both had similar weather, wet, overcast and cold. What many don't realize is that the average rainfall for a place like York is considerably less than for Dallas. In fact, Dallas generally gets 50% more rainfall than York. Unfortunately, we can get a month's worth of rain in a few hours and go weeks without a drop. My most vivid memory of visiting Yorkshire is when a local guy took a day off to drive me to Yorkshire for sightseeing. He was a friend of the girl whose family I was staying with. He was very north English. I still recall he had a Mini Cooper, and wore a wool sweater which needed washing. There was that particular musty smell one gets from somewhat damp wool. A very nice guy. In any case, we spent the day driving around the country and visited the city of York, which is very interesting, if one likes history. Constantine the Great set out from York to conquer the Roman Empire. The York Minster is beautiful and impressive. The Crypt particularly impressed me for some reason.
|
|
Brad Nelson
Administrator
עַבְדְּךָ֔ אֶת־ הַתְּשׁוּעָ֥ה הַגְּדֹלָ֖ה הַזֹּ֑את
Posts: 12,261
|
Post by Brad Nelson on Nov 25, 2023 8:04:15 GMT -8
Yes, York Minster is spectacular. And that's a nice collection of photos on that Wiki page. The one photo of the Crypt does make it look quite interesting.
Yes, that's interesting. Seattle holds the record (or near the top) for cloudy, drizzly days...but certainly not for the amount of rainfall. But it seems like more.
The rural citizenry of Yorkshire is a mixed bag. Wight describes them as some of the most hospitable people he'd ever met. But he also describes the oddest set of oddballs I've ever heard of.
For many, their general attitude toward a vet was as a necessary evil. They didn't like paying him, either out of being cheap or being unable to do so. Many thought (or rationalized) that it was their own home remedies (usually complete nonsense superstition) that did the trick.
They seemed to have dispensed quite a bit of pro bono work, and gladly so. At heart, they seemed rather to be at the beck-and-call of the animals rather than their owners. The needs of the animals were what they were and it didn't matter if a fellow hadn't paid in a year. They would be there at 3 a.m. to help with a difficult birthing if need be.
Most of the difficult ones were just overly cantankerous, not truly bad. But for every one of these that the vets ran into there were those who were absolutely thrilled to have a visit from them and it was considered an occasion. James would be fed well at their table and very often sent home with a dozen eggs, a block of cheese, or whatever, which he would often find magically in the back seat of his car...and very often from people who by all appearances did not have two pennies to rub together.
The theme all around is of hard but satisfying work. Snowflakes need not apply to Yorkshire. I wonder what it's like today.
|
|
Brad Nelson
Administrator
עַבְדְּךָ֔ אֶת־ הַתְּשׁוּעָ֥ה הַגְּדֹלָ֖ה הַזֹּ֑את
Posts: 12,261
|
Post by Brad Nelson on Dec 20, 2023 8:43:30 GMT -8
I finished All Things Bright and Beautiful. This is definitely more of the same. But as one reviewer wrote: "The world could use more nice stories and fewer bang bang shoot 'em up, blow 'em up, everybody dies stories." It's hard to argue with that. Much of what passes for storytelling out there is pretty perverse. There's one more primary book out there ( The Lord God Made Them All), and I expect that I could get to that in time. The general story arcs through the various books is that the future lies in small-animal practice. And that's something that much later becomes a reality. In the meantime, they are pretty much stuck handling the big animals for their bread-and-butter. Herriot (Alf Wight) is honest enough in these books when he notes that many of the remedies they used in the 30's and 40's were not very effective. He frequently notes that in later years they had an effective drug for this-or-that. But in them olden days, they got by as best they could. And sometimes there was little more than harmless voodoo in what they dispensed. And the vets constantly were butting up against "home remedies" that usually were anything but. Herriot describes quite a range of Yorkshire characters. Many were gruff, but decent. It seemed more than a few were a pain to work with. They would insist the vet had done little to help, seemingly in order to get out of paying a bill. It's unknown what a typical work week was like for them. He is writing about cases that happened. And he is apparently frequently called out late at night or early in the morning. But one has no sense if this was a regular occurrence or perhaps something that happened once or twice a week. But certainly the reader gets a feel for the hardships endured in that kind of on-call practice. Despite the personality quirks of the Farnon brothers, Herriot seems to have genuinely liked them both. He writes of truly missing Tristan (who would later move on to employment at some ministry, I believe), a man-child who was often a source of misadventure but who apparently grew into a respectable and well-liked vet. Herriot describes Tristan as living somewhat of a charmed life. Things just naturally seemed to come easy for him. I guess there are people like that. There's certainly quite a bit that Herriot has left unwritten. He hints at the supposed fact that Siegfried is a bit of a babe-magnet and apparently has a regular string of women who are charmed by him. If memory serves, I don't think anything like that is mentioned or suggested in the (first) television series. All Things Bright and Beautiful is the second in what seems to be an American compendium of the series. It leaves off rather poignantly as Herriot (and Siegfried) both head off to war as they are enlisted (or enlist) in the RAF. The intent, I believe, is for ground crew due to the somewhat "protected" status of their profession. Tristan, of course, has a cushy job in the Far East taking care of horses for some unit.
|
|